Generational views of charismatic and Pentecostal Christianity

George Barna's group recently put out a study exploring the degree to which four different generations of American adults identified themselves as charismatic or Pentecostal believers.

Their research examined generational gaps in terms of beliefs about the Holy Spirit, speaking in tongues, and spiritual gifts.

Let me quote from their findings:

"Those fitting the Pentecostal/charismatic criteria stated that they considered themselves to be in that category of believers, said they believe that they “have been filled with the Holy Spirit,” and that God has given them at least one of the charismatic gifts, such as tongues, prophecy, or healing. Overall, that group represents 21% of all American adults and 25% of those who describe themselves as Christian.

Baby Busters (ages 26 to 44) were the generation of self-identified Christians most likely to claim a charismatic or Pentecostal connection (29%), slightly higher than the 26% among the Mosaics (ages 18 to 25) and the 25% among the eldest of Americans (25% among those 64 and older). Surprisingly, the generation that introduced America to “Jesus freaks” and other marks of spiritual intensity – i.e., Baby Boomers (now 45 to 63) – is the generation currently least likely to identify as charismatic or Pentecostal (20%).

In terms of beliefs and attitudes, there are marked differences between the generations. In general, the research shows that younger Christians are more open to charismatic gifts, but more skeptical about the nature of the Holy Spirit when compared to older Christians.

Christians aligned with the two youngest generations - the Mosaics (56%) and Busters (49%) - were more likely than were Boomers (44%) or Elders (30%) to believe that “the charismatic gifts, such as tongues and healing, are active and valid today.” However, age was a less consistent indicator of people’s awareness of spiritual gifts. Mosaic Christians were the most likely to be aware of such gifts, while Buster Christians the least aware age group.

Regarding the best-known and most controversial of the charismatic gifts, the spiritual prayer language known as speaking in tongues, younger Christians were more likely to believe that tongues are “valid and active today.” In total, 43% of Mosaics and Busters believe either that God provides every Christian with the ability to speak in tongues or that God gives the gift to some but not to others. This compares to 37% among Boomers and Elders combined. Still, this does not necessarily translate into greater personal participation in speaking in tongues among young believers; just 7% of Mosaic Christians and 9% of Buster Christians had ever spoken in tongues, compared to 13% of Boomer believers and 9% of Elder Christians.

The four generations also demonstrated contrasting perspectives about the Holy Spirit. Despite their skepticism about the charismatic and Pentecostal expressions of Christianity, older believers stood out from younger Christians for their likelihood of saying that they “consistently allow their lives to be guided by the Holy Spirit.” Elders (64%) and Boomers (59%) outpaced Busters (54%) and Mosaics (38%) on this viewpoint.

In spite of their openness to the charismatic and Pentecostal elements of the Christian faith, the youngest believers offered an unexpected, existentialist view of the Holy Spirit. In total, 68% of Mosaic Christians said they believe that the third person of the trinity is just “a symbol of God’s power or presence, but is not a living entity.” This compares to 59% of Busters, 55% of Boomers, and 56% of Elders who believe the Holy Spirit is merely symbolic.

Younger Christians were more likely than older believers to “sense that God is motivating people to stay connected with him, but in different ways and through different types of experiences than has been the case in the past.” A majority of Busters (52%) strongly embraced this perspective, while Boomers (43%) and Elders (39%) were less likely to do so."

Now then, the very fact that the Barna group even attempted to do such a study is meaningful to me. I believe it shows that we as Pentecostals are making an impact in our culture, especially in the religious culture of America.

Let me break down their observations from the above data:

The Charismatic and Pentecostal community, by the sheer size of its numbers, has established itself as a group with significant social and spiritual force.

Generational changes and the diffusion of Pentecostalism across many denominations have made its beliefs, behaviors and identities much less focused.

For millions of younger christian, charismatic, Pentecostal and Spirit-filled labels are not as divisive as they were to their parents' generation.

The next generation of charismatic and Pentecostal Christians will spend less time defending their views to others, but also will be less certain of what they believe or how to put their faith into action.

The premium, and needed focus, will be for theological and spiritual development.

All of this excites me for this reason: As we move out to 183rd street, we are saying to ourselves that we will be a great Charismatic/Pentecostal choice for seekers and churched people looking for a more expressive church home.

May we continue with the vision that God has given us.